All In for Revolution

In a stark example of "optimism of the will" (a Gramscian term), a group called Climaximo has published a book titled All In: A Revolutionary Theory to Stop Climate Collapse. True to its title, the program they put forward does not mess around with the usual "non-reformist reforms" nor mitigation, much less adaptation strategies.No.They go straight to the crux of the bisquit, stating clearly that there isn't time for tinkering around the edges and anything less than replacing capitalism will fail to save us. This truth is glaringly obvious, necessary and impossible, leaving us torn between hope and "pessimism of the intellect". Even the term "all in" challenges our post-post-modern sensiblities, our jaded cynicism and claims on capitalist realism. Who goes "all in" in these times of grim grotesqueries and moronic masquerades? Immersed in the farcicle, we cringe with embarrassment at the true believers... We know perfectly well but act as if we don't in order to protect ourselves from further trauma. And yet the case for revolution now is incredibly evident. Every plea for working from "inside the system" is laughably hollow as every "progressive" reform is demolished with reactionary glee. The authors recognize these social frictions to be part of the "State of Emergency", along with ecological collapse. It is noteworthy that they look to Naomi Klein's seminal work, This Changes Everything, as a founding document. Everything means everything, and yes, the ruling class also noticed that book. Hence, the prolonged, all out attack on all things Marx, Left, Woke or sustainable. Or Just. Where All In falters, in terms of theory, is the place where so much modern theory falters; trying to identify the revolutionary agent. Based in a Marxian understanding of class, they turn to the forces of production and find an uncooperative subject. Why don't they recognize their exploitation? Why don't they have a sense of class belonging? Why is alienation expressed in reactionary complicity and a hegemonic consent? Climaximo admits to this failure to link up with labor and build the solidarity Leftists find so crucial to success. I admire their willingness to admit failure and re-evaluate theory based on experience. And I admire their tenacity in the face of daunting odds, this optimism of the will.I wonder if they might consider the ecological class? Fortunately, Climaximo's praxis demonstrates an ability to foment radical change without perfect class alignment. They count as a success "normalizing civil disobedience in Portugal", a tactic I believe is critical for building the anti-capitalist, climate justice movement. Who knows if it can hapem in time. But you have to admire the spirit guiding the effort. Perhaps if we are All In?

Project Esther

As the genocide in Gaza intensifies and Zionist settlers murder American citizens with impunity and the Israeli state attacks Syria and Lebanon with impunity, you might think the good citizens of America would wonder why. But you would be wrong. Ezra Klein makes an attempt to intervene, explaining the contradiction between a settler/colonialist/ethno-state with expanionist ambitions ie.. Zionism, and the liberal ideals that many American Jews value such as the right to self-determination, secularist governance, etc... Unfortunately, Ezra doesn't go so far as to to call the Zionist state of Israel genocidal, but he hints that it is a conclusion difficult to avoid. Already the Lobby has Mamdani parsing language like "global infitada" and American Zionists, especially the Christian types, will do everything they can to make sure everyone knows he has "Islamist" leanings. Not to mention socialist. I just hope he finds a way to lean into this particular criticism rather than the typical backing away. The photos of wealthy real estate developers handing his opponents big checks makes this the perfect opportunity to clarify who stands for what. This brings us to Project Esther, a paper put out by the now-ascendent Heritage Foundation. The paper outlines a strategy to not just marginalize but destroy the cause of Palestinian liberation from Israeli occupiers and oppressors. They were the inspired thinkers behind this program to smear any and all with the label of anti-semitic, a program which has succeeded beyond their wildest dreams (or so I would imagine). Get a few Jewish students on various campuses to claim they "feel threatened" when pro-Palestinian or anti-Zionist voices are raised. Get a few rabid Republican Zionists to do their own threatening; taking away funding, suing, creating bad publicity, etc.. Get politicians on both sides of the aisle to equate anti-Zionism with anti-semitism. Keep talking about the defenseless Israelis in their dangerous neighborhood. Yada yada.

Totally Limited Trout

Just got my notice from Trout Unlimited about river closures and fishing restrictions, a now annual event. Though this may be the earliest in memory. When there is only one trout left in Montana they will be saying, yes, we know climate change is the problem and therefore we must conserve even harder. Unable to think, much less act, structurally, they believe in individual solutions like catch and release. Volunteer to plant some willows. Call your "representative". Whatever. Like good frogs, we slowly boil with barely a shrug. All this talk of "meeting the Paris goals" is indicative of how delusional we truly are. We are all at the Mystic Summer camp, listening to the pounding of the rain on the roof, trying to recall the evacuation plan, pulling the pillow over our heads. After the destruction we head to church and praise the first responders. Watch a president tour the ruins, over and over and over again. Chide those plaing the "blame game". I wonder if Trout Unlimited did conservation work on the Guadalupe River? The point of all this obfuscation is the desperate attempt to save capitalism from itself. As an ideology, it's legitimacy hinges on making all other systems look like hellscapes. As a form of production it hinges on providing cheap consumer goods and credit to the masses and luxury for the elites. This is why China is such a threat; the people seem relatively happy and they are totally annihilating neoliberal capitalist countries in economic terms. Now the capitalists are directing their ire at poor Cuba. So sick, so pathetic, so American.

Theocracy and Hypocrisy

The mainstream commentary bristles with denunciations of Iran as an Islamic state, an unenlightened theocracy - but do you ever hear anyone describe Israel as a Jewish state? And the irony of evangelical fanatics like Mike Huckabee doing the denouncing is totally missed. The USA is crammed with people who pine for a Christian nation, yet freak out over the thought of an Ayatollah being in charge. And what about the fact that Iran absolutely cannot have a nuclear bomb but everyone knows that Israel illegally possesses lots of them ( but politely refrains from mentioning it ). They expect us ( the peons) to take international law seriously while a rogue state, and close ally like Israel flaunts it at every opportunity. Can you imagine what US leaders and the media would be saying if China were committing the kind of genocide Israel currently is? Or indiscriminately bombing and rocketing its neighbors, like Israel is doing to Lebanon and Syria? And then there is our good friends the Saudis. I know. Hypocricy isn't a thing when everyone does it. Like a fish not noticing water. A neighbor of mine flies a large flag that is half stars and stripes and half Israeli flag. Nobody says a word about his loyalty.